Euroispa
  • About
    • Who we are
    • Partners
    • Articles of Association
  • Committees
  • Intermediary Liability
  • News
  • Join us
  • Contact
  • Menu Menu

Terrorist Content Online: EuroISPA concerned as Commission privatises law enforcement

12th September 2018/in 2018 /by der-adminv-on-euroispa

Brussels, 12 September 2018- Less than one week after the transposition of the Directive on Combatting Terrorism, the European Commission has published its proposal on “preventing the dissemination of terrorist content online”. EuroISPA strongly criticises the steps towards the further privatisation of law enforcement, as the proposal would oblige hosting service providers to proactively decide on the legality of allegedly terrorist content, with profound implications for fundamental rights and freedoms. Malcolm Hutty, Intermediary Liability Chair, stated: "Handing off responsibility for detecting terrorist content to internet intermediaries is passing off one of the State's most fundamental responsibilities. Internet companies can neither identify terrorist content reliably, nor act as guarantors for freedom speech. Only competent public authorities have the ability to protect both our safety and our freedoms. The proper role for Internet companies is simply to act swiftly to remove material that an independent authority has determined to be illegal by due process of law".

With this proposal the Commission mandates a large part of the Internet value chain to proactively decide on the legality and nature of content online, following a risk assessment of their service. Such requirements, combined with vaguely defined duty of care obligations are deeply worrying, raising issues of transparency, legal clarity, accountability and certainty. As a result, fundamental freedoms of expression as well as of sharing and receiving information are endangered.

The proposal’s provision for a one-hour timeframe poses risks to due process and legal clarity. This timeframe, combined with sanctions, is simply not feasible for SMEs, who do not have the resources to provide a 24/7 service. Therefore, an SME exemption should be included, in order not to disadvantage SMEs vis-à-vis larger platforms.

The included data retention obligation, running contrary to existing case-law, is equally concerning. The vast range of data covered by the scope of the Regulation will ultimately endanger European users’ privacy. Moreover, the possibility for competent authorities to renew the data retention obligations an unlimited number of times might prove extremely burdensome for SMEs.

While technological progress and service providers’ efforts have led to a higher rate of removal of terrorist content in recent months, filtering only constitutes a quick fix. It does not solve the root issues of dealing with the perpetrators or providing justice to victims.

Dedicated Single Points of Contact (SPOCs) and referral units, such as Europol’s Internet Referral Unit, work closely in collaboration with Internet Service Providers (ISPs). These existing procedures have dramatically accelerated the removal of terrorist content online. However, EuroISPA expresses its concerns over the tendency in privatising law enforcement activities, placing this responsibility in the hands of ISPs. EuroISPA calls for careful consideration of this proposal, to strive towards greater legal clarity, transparency and accountability in line with legal safeguards. Due consideration should be given to already existing voluntary processes, and the close cooperation between industry and law enforcement. This voluntary approach has proven thus far to be efficient and effective in tackling terrorist content online.

https://www.euroispa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/EuroISPA_featured_image28.jpg 720 1170 der-adminv-on-euroispa https://www.euroispa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/logo_euroispa_4c_invers_2-300x127.png der-adminv-on-euroispa2018-09-12 10:04:022020-02-18 12:09:10Terrorist Content Online: EuroISPA concerned as Commission privatises law enforcement

Search

News Archive

Tags

Board Child Safety Online; Safer Internet; Hotlines Commission Work Programme Connected Continent consultation Copyright Copyright infringement Copyright in the information society Directive Digital Services Act Digital Single Market DSA e-commerce Election European Commission HostingCon Intellectual Property Rights Intermediary Liability IPR Jean-Claude Juncker NetzDG Press Release

Latest News

  • Statement16th December 2020 - 2:05 pm
  • Press Release: EuroISPA Announces Election of New Board23rd November 2020 - 5:04 pm

Contact details

EuroISPA 38 Rue de la Loi 1000 Brussels

Tel. +32 27 89 66 18

Mail. secretariat@euroispa.org

Join our mailing list

General contact information | Privacy policy

Copyright Vote – EuroISPA’s recommendations EuroISPA regrets Plenary vote on Copyright
Scroll to top

Privacy settings In order to enhance user experience and for better presentation of content, this website uses cookies.

Accept cookie settingsIndividual cookie settings

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

This website uses “session cookies" which are only temporarily stored on your computer and are technically necessary for the provision of the service. As soon as the web browser is closed, they are deleted again.
In addition, this website uses “permanent cookies” for the member login, which enables the website to recognize, that a user has already provided a username and password. Additionally, a cookie is used for the acceptance of the cookie notice on our website. These permanent cookies are stored for 30 days.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, you cannot refuse them without impacting how our site functions. You can block or delete them by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website.

Google Web fonts

We also use Google Webfonts. Since the provider of this service may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Privacy Policy

You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.

Privacy policy
1
Accept settingsHide notification only