EuroISPA
  • About
    • Who we are
    • Committees
    • Partners
    • Articles of Association
  • News
  • DSA in Focus
  • mySCCcreator
  • Contact
    • Contact us
    • Join us
  • Menu Menu

EuroISPA sceptical about EU Commission’s plan to task vigilantes with guarding the Internet

01/03/2018/in 2018

Brussels, 1st March 2018: Upon the adoption of the European Commission’s Recommendation on measures to effectively tackle illegal content online, EuroISPA has reiterated that the rule of law must not be sacrificed in the fight against illegal content online. Today’s Recommendation demands that Internet intermediaries are bound to suppress content at the request of state investigators or vigilante actors, without any independent assessment of legality. This places Internet businesses at risk of violating their obligations to respect fundamental rights in the online sphere.

The Recommendation proposes the use of automated filters to assess the legality of content, which will lead to over-blocking and censorship of lawful content. Proactive measures, especially in combination with such automated filtering methods, clearly run counter to recent jurisprudence of both the Court of Justice of the European Union as well as Member State court rulings.

Burdening Internet intermediaries with such immense responsibilities is not only troubling due to the lack of court oversight, it also serves to further reinforce the worrying trend of the privatisation of law enforcement online. This deeply disquieting tendency is further sharpened by the Recommendation’s encouragement of dealing with disputes with an out-of-court settlement mechanism, and by the extremely limited time frame of just one hour, within which Internet intermediaries are expected to remove content upon referral. EuroISPA is especially alarmed as such extreme time constraints clearly reflect that European law-makers fail to understand that such obligations would be almost impossible to put in place for the vast number of small and medium size businesses all over Europe.

EuroISPA is furthermore troubled by the recommendation that Internet intermediaries should simply comply with demands to remove content from private vigilante organisations, which the European Commission designates as “trusted flaggers”. The proliferation of such entities, with the suggestion to extend these competences further to users and copyright holders, shows the Commission’s worrisome acceptance of the absence of court oversight and supports a system afflicted with a clear lack of impartiality: the entity making the complaint would often be the same which assesses the validity of the complaint.

Such an approach would also have severe detrimental effects on the current system of hotlines, whose valuable work on tackling Child Sexual Abuse Material online would be undermined.  EuroISPA thus points out that, without the need of a court order, the increased power of referrals and take down or access restriction orders by competent authorities, will make it impossible to uphold due process and the rule of law online.

EuroISPA, and its over 2,500 member companies from all areas of the European internet ecosystem, have long been and continue to be dedicated in leading the fight against illegal content online, notably through its Members responsible for national hotlines, as well as supporting anti-malware and anti-spam initiatives across Europe. We reiterate our call for a policy framework to tackle illegal content online only in the context of due process and strong judicial oversight. Fundamental freedoms of European Internet users must be upheld, which can only be ensured through a system underpinned by court authority.

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
0 0 Secretariat https://www.euroispa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/logo_euroispa_4c_invers_2-300x127.png Secretariat2018-03-01 13:41:282020-01-23 13:22:28EuroISPA sceptical about EU Commission’s plan to task vigilantes with guarding the Internet

Search

Latest Posts

  • EuroISPA Annual Policy Report 2021
  • PRESS RELEASE: EuroISPA elects new Officers during November General Meeting
  • PRESS RELEASE: Freedom Internet becomes EuroIPSA Industry Forum’s newest member
  • Position Paper on the Proposal for a Regulation laying down rules to prevent and combat child sexual abuse
  • PRESS RELEASE: EuroISPA voices concerns regarding CSAM proposal’s impact on user privacy

Tags

Board Child Safety Online Child Sexual Abuse Material Commission Work Programme Connected Continent consultation Copyright Copyright infringement Copyright in the information society Directive CSAM Digital Services Act Digital Single Market DSA e-commerce Election eprivacy European Commission GDPR Hotlines Intellectual Property Rights Intermediary Liability IPR Jean-Claude Juncker NetzDG Position Paper Press Release Safer Internet

Contact details

EuroISPA

38, Rue de la Loi
1000 Brussels

+32 2 789 6618

[email protected]

General contact information | Privacy policy

Marking Safer Internet Day 2018EuroISPA welcomes the European Commission’s Communication on AI, but warns...
Scroll to top