Euroispa
  • About
    • Who we are
    • Partners
    • Articles of Association
  • Committees
  • Intermediary Liability
  • News
  • Join us
  • Contact
  • Menu Menu

Scarlet extended case: the European Court of Justice’s clarification will foster innovation and growth

30th March 2013/0 Comments/in Uncategorised /by der-adminv-on-euroispa

Brussels,  24 November 2011- The European Internet Services Providers Association (EuroISPA) welcomes the Court of Justice’s ruling that network providers cannot be required to engage in large scale filtering of all users’ communications.

November 2011. EuroISPA and its members welcome the Court of Justice’s clarification in the Scarlet extended case that existing EU law preclude network providers from implementing systems for large scale filtering and blocking of users’ electronic communications. This ruling guarantees the protection under EU law  of fundamental rights and the freedom  of a network provider to conduct  its business. Intellectual property rights should be respected but are  not inviolable, and disproportionate technical enforcement that infringes on the rights of others is contrary to EU law.

The court ruled that requiring Internet Service Providers to conduct general filtering of Internet traffic to prevent copyright infringement is incompatible with the Electronic Commerce Directive and with fundamental rights.  Requiring an ISP to install  such a complicated, costly computer system at its own expense is a serious infringement of the freedom to conduct business. What is more, such systematic analysis of all  content passing through the network undermines both the customers’ right  to protection of their personal data and their right to receive and impart information.

The ruling from the Court of Justice of the EU will have serious implications for content blocking systems imposed on ISPs in other Member States, especially where these are also maintained at the ISP’s expense.

“The Internet industry  plays  a  crucial  part in connecting  European citizens  and  businesses  to  information,  news, entertainment, social media, cultural content and other public interest content. This ruling is therefore of fundamental importance for the future of the Internet and the development of a strong Digital Single Market,” said Malcolm Hutty, President of EuroISPA

“Considering the major contribution that the Internet  industry can make to the economic recovery, it was indeed not the time to put  the  innovation  of the Internet  at risk, and it is of fundamental importance for the future of the Internet that the principles reaffirmed in the ruling are respected”, he continued.

Background

By a judgment on 29 June 2007, the Belgian ISP Scarlet was ordered to install a filtering system to monitor all peer-to-peer traffic on its network and  to  block  the exchange of  files which were included in the repertoire of collecting society SABAM. Scarlet appealed against that judgment to the  Court of Appeal of Brussels, which must  now  decide whether to uphold the measure adopted against Scarlet. In that context, the Court sought a ruling from the Court of Justice on whether EU law permits national courts to order ISPs to install a system for filtering and blocking electronic communications.

0 0 der-adminv-on-euroispa https://www.euroispa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/logo_euroispa_4c_invers_2-300x127.png der-adminv-on-euroispa2013-03-30 11:33:152013-03-30 11:33:15Scarlet extended case: the European Court of Justice’s clarification will foster innovation and growth
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Search

News Archive

Tags

Board Child Safety Online; Safer Internet; Hotlines Commission Work Programme Connected Continent consultation Copyright Copyright infringement Copyright in the information society Directive Digital Services Act Digital Single Market DSA e-commerce Election European Commission HostingCon Intellectual Property Rights Intermediary Liability IPR Jean-Claude Juncker NetzDG Press Release

Latest News

  • Statement16th December 2020 - 2:05 pm
  • Press Release: EuroISPA Announces Election of New Board23rd November 2020 - 5:04 pm

Contact details

EuroISPA 38 Rue de la Loi 1000 Brussels

Tel. +32 27 89 66 18

Mail. secretariat@euroispa.org

Join our mailing list

General contact information | Privacy policy

ICT industry joins forces on data protection in Europe EU institutions adopt directive on child sexual exploitation
Scroll to top

Privacy settings In order to enhance user experience and for better presentation of content, this website uses cookies.

Accept cookie settingsIndividual cookie settings

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

This website uses “session cookies" which are only temporarily stored on your computer and are technically necessary for the provision of the service. As soon as the web browser is closed, they are deleted again.
In addition, this website uses “permanent cookies” for the member login, which enables the website to recognize, that a user has already provided a username and password. Additionally, a cookie is used for the acceptance of the cookie notice on our website. These permanent cookies are stored for 30 days.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, you cannot refuse them without impacting how our site functions. You can block or delete them by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website.

Google Web fonts

We also use Google Webfonts. Since the provider of this service may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Privacy Policy

You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.

Privacy policy
1
Accept settingsHide notification only